The conversation surrounding Netflix’s Nobody Wants This has taken an unexpected turn, bringing its creator and one of its leading stars into the spotlight over their differing views on Israel and Palestine. Erin Foster has now addressed Adam Brody’s public comments, offering a response that acknowledges their disagreement while making clear that it has not erased her affection for her co-star.
But Foster’s remarks go beyond the political controversy. As audiences return to the series for Season 3, she is also using the moment to explain why Jewish representation remains central to the show and what she hopes its Jewish viewers take away from it.
Erin Foster Addresses Adam Brody’s Israel and Palestine Comments
Erin Foster discussed Adam Brody’s comments in a preview clip from an upcoming episode of Amanda Hirsch’s Not Skinny But Not Fat podcast. The full episode is scheduled for October 27, 2026, meaning the remarks currently available come from a preview rather than the complete interview.
Asked about Brody’s public position, Foster described the situation as complicated. She compared the atmosphere on the Nobody Wants This set to conversations that take place around dinner tables, where people can debate major issues and disagree without necessarily ending their relationships.
“You know, it’s complicated. I think our work environment, our set is very similar to dinner tables around the world where people are having debate and discussion and disagreeing,” Foster said.
She then made her own position clear, acknowledging that her views differ from those of the actor who plays Rabbi Noah Roklov in the Netflix series.
“While I love Adam, I also disagree with him. And that’s okay,” she said.
Foster’s response draws a distinction between personal relationships and political opinions. Rather than suggesting that disagreement makes it impossible to work together, she emphasized that people can maintain professional relationships while holding different perspectives.
There has been no announcement that Brody is leaving Nobody Wants This, being replaced, or facing disciplinary action from Netflix because of his political comments. He remains part of Season 3, which is currently available to stream.
More on the Latest Season of Nobody Wants This
The third season continues Joanne and Noah’s relationship as the series explores its next chapter. Read our Nobody Wants This Season 3 review for a closer look at the new episodes.
Why Erin Foster Calls Nobody Wants This a “Love Letter to Judaism”
Foster’s response also offered a closer look at the creative intentions behind Nobody Wants This. For her, the series is not simply a romantic comedy about two people from different backgrounds. Jewish identity and representation are fundamental to the story she wanted to tell.
Addressing Jewish viewers directly, Foster explained that she wanted them to feel acknowledged and understood through the series.
“I think that as the creator of the show, all I can say is that I want our Jewish fans to know that I see you and I hear you and I understand how you feel,” she said.
She described the programme as “a love letter to Judaism”, connecting its purpose to her own experience of becoming Jewish and living as a Jewish person.
“That is why I made this show,” Foster said.
She also expressed the view that positive representation of Jewish people is particularly important at the current time. Her comments underline why she sees the series as a personal and meaningful project rather than just another relationship-focused television show.
However, Foster was careful to distinguish her creative intentions from Brody’s individual political views.
“That being said, everyone is entitled to a different opinion than me,” she said. “I can just tell you what I created this show for, what the intention of the show is.”
Her remarks do not present Brody’s views as the official position of Nobody Wants This. Instead, they explain what the series means to its creator while acknowledging that people involved in the production can hold different opinions.
What Adam Brody Said About Israel, Gaza and Palestine
The discussion follows a September 2026 interview Brody gave to GQ as part of a profile examining his political activism ahead of the 2026 US midterm elections.
During the interview, Brody was asked whether the Israel-Gaza conflict had come up while he was involved in political organising. He explained that he had discussed the issue privately but had not spoken about it extensively in public.
“Truthfully, it hasn’t. I have spoken a lot about it privately. I haven’t spoken much about it publicly,” Brody said.
When asked whether he wanted to share his position publicly, the actor responded with a direct statement about his assessment of the conflict.
“Put me down as thinking it’s a genocide. Put me down as wanting a free Palestine.”
Brody continued by discussing the death and suffering associated with the conflict and expressing hope that a change in US administration could lead to different policies.
“It’s awful that it’s taken so much death and misery, but it does feel like it’s reaching a breaking point that it should have a while ago. I’m hopeful that another administration can really do some good and correct some of these policies that are helping that situation be as awful as it is.”
These remarks represent Brody’s own political assessment and position. His use of the word “genocide” should be attributed to him rather than treated as an uncontested legal conclusion.
Brody also explained that he generally responds to political questions when people ask him about them, even though most questions directed at him concern his acting career.
His comments subsequently became part of a wider conversation about the series, its Jewish themes and the different perspectives held by people associated with the production.
Why Adam Brody’s Political Views Became a Talking Point for the Netflix Series
The connection between Brody’s remarks and Nobody Wants This is closely tied to the character he plays.
Brody portrays Rabbi Noah Roklov, a Los Angeles rabbi who begins a relationship with Joanne, an agnostic relationship podcaster played by Kristen Bell. As their relationship develops, Joanne becomes increasingly involved in Noah’s Jewish community and eventually decides to convert to Judaism.
That storyline places Jewish identity at the centre of the series, making Brody’s public comments about Israel and Gaza a subject of discussion among viewers and people connected to the show.
Brody is Jewish but has publicly described himself as an atheist or nonreligious. He has also discussed the responsibility he felt when preparing to portray a rabbi, given his limited religious knowledge.
His role in one of Netflix’s prominent contemporary series centred on Jewish identity and relationships has therefore become part of the context surrounding the controversy.
However, Brody’s personal political views should not automatically be attributed to Noah, the fictional character, or to the series as a whole. Similarly, the character’s religious identity does not establish a single political position for everyone involved in making the programme.
Rabbi Steve Leder Criticises Brody’s Comments
The discussion has also drawn a response from Rabbi Steve Leder, who served as a Jewish consultant during Season 1 of Nobody Wants This.
Following Brody’s GQ interview, Leder criticised the actor’s use of the word “genocide” and challenged his understanding of the term.
Leder described Brody’s comments as “truly shocking,” “flippant” and “disgusting.”
He also addressed Brody directly, saying:
“You by your own admission are a relatively ignorant Jew, and your ignorance really showed the other day.”
Leder argued that someone using the term “genocide” should understand its meaning. He also expressed his own position on the conflict, stating that “there is no genocide in Gaza.”
These remarks reflect Leder’s personal position. They should not be interpreted as an official statement from Netflix, the show itself or every member of its creative team.
The contrasting responses from Brody and Leder illustrate how the controversy has generated disagreement among people associated with the series, rather than establishing one shared viewpoint across the production.
Tovah Feldshuh Responds to Calls to Boycott Nobody Wants This Season 3
Tovah Feldshuh, who plays Noah’s mother, Bina, has also addressed the discussion surrounding Brody’s comments.
On October 20, 2026, Feldshuh responded to criticism of the show and calls for viewers to boycott Season 3 because of Brody’s remarks. In an Instagram post, she encouraged people to remember her own position.
“Sweethearts, I understand your point of view, but remember you know where I stand.”
Feldshuh also wrote about Jewish identity, antisemitism and her belief that circumstances would change.
She returned to the subject in an Instagram comment on October 21, responding to criticism that members of the Nobody Wants This cast had not spoken publicly about the controversy.
“Adam Brody is a beloved colleague and I am speaking to him privately,” Feldshuh wrote.
She added that she had already made her views clear publicly and referenced her advocacy surrounding Jewish causes and the fight against antisemitism.
Feldshuh’s comments provide another perspective from within the cast. However, they do not establish a unified position among everyone involved with the show, and her statement about speaking privately with Brody does not indicate that the entire cast shares the same views.
Erin Foster Previously Explained Why the Show Avoids the Israel-Palestine Conflict
Foster’s latest comments also follow an earlier explanation of the series’ approach to political subjects.
According to reporting by Hey Alma, Foster addressed the Israel-Palestine issue in an October 2025 interview with The Free Press. She explained that the conflict was deliberately excluded from the show’s storyline.
“We never say Israel or Palestine in the show, and that’s intentional because I think it would be a distraction and that this is just not the show to tell that story.”
Foster also said that the series did not discuss the Holocaust.
Her earlier explanation aligns with her latest comments about the show’s purpose. She has framed Nobody Wants This primarily as a story about relationships, Judaism, family and personal identity, rather than as a political series about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Consequently, her recent response does not introduce a new political storyline into the show. Instead, it reiterates the distinction between the subject matter Foster intended to explore and the individual political views of people involved in the production.
How Erin Foster’s Personal Experience Inspired Nobody Wants This
The importance Foster places on Jewish representation is connected to the origins of the series.
Nobody Wants This was inspired partly by her own experience of becoming Jewish before marrying music executive Simon Tikhman. The central relationship between Joanne and Noah draws on the differences between Joanne’s background and Noah’s life as a rabbi.
As the story progresses, Joanne becomes more interested in Judaism and ultimately decides to convert. That journey continues in Season 3, alongside the development of her relationship with Noah.
Netflix’s official Season 3 material confirms that Joanne and Noah are now living together and that Joanne is beginning the next stage of her conversion journey.
Sarah Silverman joins the series as Rabbi Eden, who leads Joanne’s conversion class, while Andrew Rannells plays Sebastian, another student. Foster also makes an onscreen appearance during the third season.
These storylines reinforce the importance of Judaism to the series, helping explain why Foster describes the show as a personal expression of her experience rather than a vehicle for presenting a single political viewpoint.
Nobody Wants This Season 3 Release Date and Cast Details
The timing of Foster’s remarks coincides with the latest season’s arrival on Netflix.
Netflix released all 10 episodes of Nobody Wants This Season 3 on October 22, 2026. The season begins with Joanne and Noah having moved in together, shifting the focus towards the next stage of their relationship rather than another question of whether they will become a couple.
The confirmed Season 3 cast additions include Sarah Silverman, Andrew Rannells, Keyla Monterroso Mejia, Avan Jogia, Poorna Jagannathan, Sadie Sandler, Stephanie Koenig and Steven Weber. Foster also makes a cameo.
The series continues to focus on its established themes of relationships, family and Judaism.
Nothing in Netflix’s current official Season 3 material indicates that Brody’s political comments have changed the storyline or affected his position as Noah.
| Detail | Confirmed information |
| Series | Nobody Wants This |
| Creator | Erin Foster |
| Adam Brody’s character | Rabbi Noah Roklov |
| Kristen Bell’s character | Joanne |
| Season 3 release date | October 22, 2026 |
| Number of Season 3 episodes | 10 |
| Podcast | Not Skinny But Not Fat, hosted by Amanda Hirsch |
| Scheduled podcast episode | October 27, 2026 |
| Additional cast members | Sarah Silverman, Andrew Rannells, Keyla Monterroso Mejia, Avan Jogia, Poorna Jagannathan, Sadie Sandler, Stephanie Koenig and Steven Weber |
Has Adam Brody Left Nobody Wants This After the Controversy?
As of October 24, 2026, Brody remains credited as Noah Roklov in Season 3, which is available to stream on Netflix. The season’s official promotional and cast material continues to feature him alongside Kristen Bell.
There has been no announcement that Brody is leaving the series, that his character is being replaced, or that Netflix has taken disciplinary action against him because of his political comments.
The current development is therefore not a confirmed cast change or a rewritten storyline. Instead, the public conversation surrounding Nobody Wants This has expanded to include differing views about Israel and Palestine among people associated with the show.
Foster has explicitly said that she loves Brody while disagreeing with him. Feldshuh has described Brody as a beloved colleague and said she is speaking to him privately, while Leder has publicly criticised his remarks. These responses represent individual perspectives, not a single position attributable to the entire cast or production team.
Foster’s full conversation with Hirsch is scheduled for October 27, 2026. Until the complete episode is released, the comments currently being reported remain those made available in the preview clip.
Revisit Joanne and Noah’s Story From the Beginning
The series’ central relationship and its exploration of Jewish identity began in its first season. Catch up with our Nobody Wants This Season 1 recap before diving further into the new season.
Conclusion
Erin Foster’s response to Adam Brody’s “Free Palestine” comments highlights a disagreement between two people involved in Nobody Wants This, while making clear that their differing political views have not been publicly linked to a change in the show’s cast or storyline.
Foster has used the discussion to reaffirm her intention to make the series a “love letter to Judaism” and to provide meaningful Jewish representation. Meanwhile, responses from Rabbi Steve Leder and Tovah Feldshuh demonstrate that people connected to the production have expressed different views about Brody’s remarks.
With all 10 episodes of Season 3 now streaming on Netflix, the series continues its story about relationships, family and Jewish identity. For now, Foster’s position remains clear: she disagrees with Brody, but believes that people can hold different opinions and continue working together.
Source and Research Disclaimer: This article has been prepared based on research of the sources listed below and the information available in the supplied material. Statements, quotations, reported events and positions are attributed to the individuals or publications identified in that material. The article does not claim independent verification beyond the information supported by those sources. Foster’s full podcast interview is scheduled for October 27, 2026, and further context may become available when the complete episode is released.
Sources
- Deadline — Erin Foster responds to Adam Brody’s “Free Palestine” comments
- Entertainment Weekly — Preview of Erin Foster’s podcast interview
- TheWrap — Erin Foster and Adam Brody’s Israel comments
- Jewish Telegraphic Agency — Adam Brody’s comments about Gaza
- Netflix Tudum — Nobody Wants This Season 3
- Netflix Tudum — Nobody Wants This cast
- Hey Alma — Responses to Adam Brody’s Israel and Palestine comments
- The Guardian — Erin Foster responds to Adam Brody’s Palestine comments
- Adam Brody’s GQ interview (Sept 2026): “Put me down as thinking it’s a genocide. Put me down as wanting a free Palestine.”
Featured Image Credit: Montana McBirney / CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons
Leave a Reply