LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight arrives on May 22, 2026, and one of the biggest talking points surrounding TT Games’ latest brick-built adventure is who steps behind the cowl this time around. Will Arnett built a devoted following voicing Batman across the original LEGO Batman games and the 2017 LEGO Batman Movie, so replacing him was always going to draw attention. TT Games went ahead and did exactly that, bringing in a new face for the Caped Crusader. Here is everything currently confirmed about the voice cast in LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight.
Who Voices Batman in LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight?
Shai Matheson voices Batman and Bruce Wayne in LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight. TT Games moved on from Will Arnett, who had held the role since the original LEGO Batman video games and cemented it further with the 2017 LEGO Batman Movie, and brought Matheson in to lead the cast for this new chapter.
Will Arnett’s comedic, self-serious take on Batman became one of the most recognisable versions of the character in popular culture, so his absence is something fans will notice straight away. However, Matheson is far from a newcomer to the world of video game voice acting, and his portfolio gives him every reason to earn that trust.
Who Is Shai Matheson? His Previous Roles
If the name Shai Matheson is not immediately familiar, his body of work certainly will be. He has built an impressive portfolio across some of the biggest titles in gaming.
Key roles from Shai Matheson’s career:
- Lubor in Final Fantasy XVI
- Lorenzini Venigni in Lies of P
- Scar (English voice) in Wuthering Waves
- Voice roles in Resident Evil: Requiem, Star Wars Outlaws, Helldivers 2, Assassin’s Creed Mirage, Payday 3, and Horizon Forbidden West
- J.J. Campbell in Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines 2
- Marty MacChicken in Chicken Police: Into the Hive!
- Schultz in the TV mini-series Catch-22
He also previewed the role around The Game Awards 2025, where he appeared as LEGO Batman in what sources note was an early look at the character ahead of the full game’s release.
Confirmed Voice Cast So Far
As of the game’s launch window, TT Games has only officially confirmed two voice roles. The full cast list is yet to be published, though more announcements are expected as the game rolls out fully on May 22.
| Character | Voice Actor |
| Batman / Bruce Wayne | Shai Matheson |
| Bane | Matt Berry |
Who Voices Bane? Meet Matt Berry
Matt Berry takes on the role of Bane, and it is one of those casting choices that clicks the moment you hear it. Berry’s take reportedly leans into the theatrical, larger-than-life energy reminiscent of Tom Hardy’s portrayal in The Dark Knight Rises, which suits the heightened, comedic tone of a LEGO game perfectly.
Matt Berry’s notable credits include:
- 8D8 in Star Wars: The Book of Boba Fett
- Multiple roles across the Fallout series
- A role in the Minecraft Movie
- Thank Goodness You’re Here! (2024) — his only prior video game credit
Characters Confirmed in the Game (Voice Actors Pending)
Several major characters are confirmed as playable in LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight, though TT Games has not yet announced who voices them. These include:
- Robin (and his journey to becoming Nightwing)
- Nightwing
- Batgirl
- Catwoman
- Jim Gordon
- Talia al Ghul
Given the scale of the confirmed roster and the game’s story pulling from decades of Batman’s cinematic history, the full cast list should be considerably larger than the two names currently made public.
How Does Shai Matheson’s Batman Compare?
Community reaction to Matheson stepping into the role has been genuinely mixed. Some fans on platforms like Reddit have noted that moving away from Will Arnett feels like a significant change, particularly given how much of LEGO Batman’s identity was tied to Arnett’s comedic delivery. Others point out that the LEGO games have always leaned into parody, and Matheson’s performance suits that tradition well enough.
What reviewers have said about the performance:
- GameSpot noted that it sounds slightly unfamiliar when iconic lines from classic Batman films are delivered by a new voice, though the reviewer acknowledged this is a tough assignment for any actor
- Game Informer’s reviewer did not flag the voice work as a negative, focusing instead on how the game’s writing and comedic timing come together effectively
- Early impressions from the r/BatmanArkham community described Matheson’s performance as “ok,” with many fans expressing they need to hear more before forming a firm opinion
Regardless of where fan opinion lands, Matheson’s extensive gaming career means he brings genuine craft to the role. His work in Final Fantasy XVI and Lies of P in particular showed he can handle demanding, nuanced performances.
Where to Play LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight
You can play LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight across the following platforms from May 22, 2026:
- PlayStation 5
- Xbox Series X/S
- PC
- Nintendo Switch 2 (release window to be confirmed)
Deluxe Edition owners already have early access ahead of the full launch. You can purchase the game via Fanatical on PC, where it is currently listed at $61.59.
A Nod to Kevin Conroy
Beyond the casting headlines, LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight also includes an in-game tribute to the late Kevin Conroy, the voice actor widely regarded as the definitive Batman for an entire generation of fans. Conroy voiced the Dark Knight across Batman: The Animated Series and the Arkham video game series for over three decades before passing away in November 2022. The game’s acknowledgement of his legacy is a meaningful touch, and one that long-time Batman fans will appreciate deeply.
Leave a Reply