Introduction: A Confession Fans Didn’t Expect
For decades, Hilary Duff and Haylie Duff were Hollywood’s quintessential sister duo—acting together, raising kids alongside each other, and publicly praising their bond as unbreakable. But on February 20, 2026, Hilary Duff shattered that long-held image with a raw and emotional confession that stunned fans and media alike.
In a tearful CBS Mornings interview, Hilary confirmed that she is currently estranged from her older sister Haylie Duff and that her new song “We Don’t Talk” is directly inspired by their fractured relationship. The revelation has reignited public curiosity about what went wrong between the two sisters who once described each other as best friends.
This article explores Hilary Duff’s emotional statements, the meaning behind her song, verified background details about the sisters, and a timeline of events that hint at when their relationship began to unravel.
Hilary Duff Confirms Estrangement From Sister Haylie Duff
During her February 20, 2026 interview with CBS Mornings, Hilary Duff spoke candidly about the pain of not having her sister in her life. Visibly emotional, she described the estrangement as the most painful part of her existence.
“It’s definitely about my sister and just absolutely the most lonely part of my existence. It’s not having my sister in my life at the moment, and I really struggled with thinking about including that on the record.”
Hilary explained that including the deeply personal song on her album was difficult, but ultimately therapeutic.
“I didn’t necessarily choose that part, but it’s my reality, and so it was honestly like healing to say.”
She also clarified that she is not trying to criticize Haylie, emphasizing that the song reflects her own experience.
“I’m not trying to say anything bad. It’s literally just my experience, and that’s really all I feel like sharing.”
Does Hilary Duff Want Haylie to Hear the Song?
Hilary revealed that she is uncertain whether her sister will hear the track or how she might react. She expressed a focus on personal healing rather than reconciliation.
“I don’t think that that would help. I think I have to just exist as a person on my own and do what I want to do.”
She also acknowledged that estrangement is more common than people realize.
“So many people are having this experience… a lot of conversations with people are like, yeah, me too.”
Her words resonated with fans who have experienced similar family fractures.
Hints of Family Strain Before the Album Release
Three days before her album release, Hilary hinted at family tension in a Glamour cover story published on February 17, 2026.
“That’s my family. Those are the people that affect you the most… Just because you’re born into a family doesn’t mean that it always stays together. You can only control your side and your street.”
The statement foreshadowed her later confirmation and suggested the rift had been ongoing for some time.
“We Don’t Talk”: The Song That Sparked Speculation
The song “We Don’t Talk” appears as the third track on Hilary Duff’s album luck…or something, released on February 20, 2026. The album marks her first full pop project in years and was largely co-written with her husband, musician Matthew Koma.
Hilary described the album as intentionally personal and focused on real-life experiences rather than fictional storytelling.
Key Lyrics Referencing Sister Estrangement
The lyrics directly reference a sibling bond and emotional distance:
“I’m not sure when it happened / Not even sure what it was about / If I did something different / Would you feel something different?”
“’Cause we come from the same home, the same blood… the same mom.”
“People ask me how you’re doing / I wanna say amazing / But the truth is that I don’t know… We don’t talk, we don’t talk about anything anymore.”
Later verses reference jealousy, emotional distance, and a desire to reconcile, suggesting unresolved tension rather than hostility.
Hilary has stated that including the song was difficult but ultimately healing because it reflected her current truth.
Hilary and Haylie Duff: A Sisterhood Once Admired
Basic Background
| Name | Birth Date | Age (2026) | Notable Facts |
| Hilary Erhard Duff | September 28, 1987 | 38 | Actress, singer, Disney icon |
| Haylie Katherine Duff | February 19, 1985 | 41 | Actress, director, producer |
The sisters grew up in Texas and moved to Los Angeles to pursue acting careers. Their mother, Susan Duff, managed them early in their careers.
They collaborated on several projects, including:
- Material Girls (2006), in which they played sisters and Hilary served as a producer
- A cover of “Our Lips Are Sealed” for A Cinderella Story soundtrack
Hilary once described Haylie as her “number one fan,” protector, and source of comfort and safety.
A Close Family Bond Turned Distant
In 2015, after Haylie gave birth to her first daughter, Hilary publicly praised her parenting and shared heartfelt anecdotes about their children bonding. Haylie said raising kids together was something they had dreamed of since childhood.
However, their last verified public appearance together was in 2019. Since then, social media interactions and public events featuring both sisters have ceased.
Haylie Duff’s Current Life and Career
Haylie Duff is engaged to Matt Rosenberg (since April 2014) and has two daughters:
- Ryan Ava (born May 11, 2015)
- Lulu Gray (born June 5, 2018)
In 2021, Haylie moved back to Texas with her family for a quieter lifestyle during the pandemic. She transitioned from acting to directing projects like Project Baby and Killer Nurses.
In 2025, she spoke positively about a potential Material Girls sequel but noted that both sisters needed to “find their own way.”
Hilary Duff’s Family Life Today
Hilary Duff is married to Matthew Koma and has four children:
- Luca (from her marriage to Mike Comrie)
- Banks
- Mae
- Townes
Her album luck…or something is largely inspired by her personal life, relationships, and motherhood.
Timeline of Estrangement Indicators
| Time | Event | Details |
| Pre-2019 | Close public relationship | Frequent collaborations and mutual praise |
| 2019 | Last public appearance together | No joint photos or events since |
| Nov 2025 | Rolling Stone interview | Hilary teased sharing “family drama” in music |
| Jan 2026 | Hilary performs “We Don’t Talk” | Fans speculate about Haylie |
| Jan 2026 | Mom-group rumors | Ashley Tisdale essay liked by Haylie; Koma’s cryptic Instagram post |
| Feb 17, 2026 | Glamour hints | Hilary discusses family fractures |
| Feb 20, 2026 | CBS Mornings confirmation | Hilary publicly confirms estrangement |
What Caused the Rift?
As of February 21, 2026, no verified cause has been publicly confirmed. Hilary has stated she does not know exactly when or why the rift occurred, describing it as something that gradually happened.
People magazine reached out to Haylie Duff’s representatives for comment, but no response or public statement has been issued by Haylie herself.
Hilary Duff’s Focus on Healing, Not Drama
Rather than escalating the situation, Hilary emphasized personal growth and healing. She framed the estrangement as a common family experience and avoided assigning blame.
Her willingness to share such vulnerability has resonated with fans, many of whom praised her honesty and emotional transparency.
Why This Story Resonates With Fans
Family estrangement is often stigmatized or hidden, especially among celebrities who typically project perfect family images. Hilary Duff’s candid admission breaks that illusion and highlights the reality that even close relationships can fracture over time.
Her song and interview provide a rare glimpse into the emotional cost of such distance—and the complicated process of accepting it.
What Happens Next for the Duff Sisters?
As of now, reconciliation remains uncertain. Hilary has not ruled it out but has emphasized that she is focusing on living her own life and processing her feelings through music.
With Haylie yet to respond publicly, the situation remains one-sided in the public eye. Fans continue to speculate, but both sisters have largely kept the details private.
Conclusion: A Personal Story Turned Public Narrative
Hilary Duff’s revelation about her estrangement from Haylie Duff marks one of the most vulnerable moments of her career. Through “We Don’t Talk” and her CBS interview, she has turned personal pain into art—offering both honesty and relatability.
Whether the sisters eventually reconcile remains to be seen, but Hilary’s message is clear: healing begins with truth, even when that truth is difficult to share.
Leave a Reply